(broadcast stream
) (.wma download
)
Do medical malpractice lawsuits significantly increase the cost of buying malpractice insurance? Or are insurers rapidly increasing their rates for other reasons?
The classic Doctor v. Lawyer Debate!
Guest Dr. Russell Libby, Former President of the Northern Virginia Medical Society debates Trial Attorney David Bernhard
This show will be televised on Channel 10 in Northern Virginia.
It's yet another plan to benefit the very rich.
Posted by: davesecho at February 12, 2005 6:40 PMI went into the hospital for an appendectomy and got a sniptodichtomy--could Dr. Libby put a dollar amount on that, and the resultant hormone treatments?
Posted by: Alice, formerly Alex at February 13, 2005 11:57 AMAlice - formerly Alex -
The first question to ask you is - are you happy being Alice or do you want to return as Alex?
Posted by: Dr. Feelgood at February 14, 2005 8:27 AMDr. Feelgood--I'm conflicted--I like to look pretty--but hate to shave my legs--I just tell everyone I'm European--I was fitted with a prosthesis--but then my dog ate it and then my medicare ran out
Posted by: Alice at February 14, 2005 9:15 AMAlice-Alex: We can take care of the nuisance of shaving those hairy legs; hot boiling wax applied and then ripped off when hardened will leave your legs smooth and supple for 6 weeks.
I'm thinking you're a good candidate for remaining Alice. We've got the hormones to do the job. We'll plump you in all the right places with a dose of estrogen and then a dose of progesterone.
Interested? Call 1-800-BIG-BOOB today!
Posted by: Dr. Feelgood at February 14, 2005 2:27 PMDr. Feelgood--will I still be a size 4? And will the hormones take care of my 5 o'clock shadow?
Posted by: Alice at February 14, 2005 4:04 PMDr Feelgood,
Can you help me out? I always wanted to be a sheep.
Posted by: Bah Bah at February 14, 2005 4:06 PMMark, How's your sense of humor?
I have to confess that this little exchange has given me a few laughs today. I do think Gordon and Skip might be related. ;-)
Posted by: Vicky at February 14, 2005 7:01 PMSick sense of humor here and then others encouraging with their laughing.
Posted by: Jen at February 15, 2005 8:39 AMI'm not sure what any of this has to do with tort reform...but it is harmless, and, in a sick way, funny.
Posted by: Mark Levine at February 15, 2005 10:47 AMJen
Excuse me if I offended you with finding this humorous - maybe another day it wouldn't have hit me the same way but yeah I laughed.
Mark, maybe "Alice" misread and thought it said "Tart Reform"?
Posted by: Vicky at February 15, 2005 11:00 AMJen--I find your outrage strangely appealing--what is your breeding curriculum? Do you have medical insurance? Would you have an objection to rearing half-lizard, half-human babies? (Not sure which half)--you will be well-compensated with Earth money
Posted by: Gort Beranga, messenger to Urantia at February 15, 2005 11:45 AMOh Vicky, now that's REALLY bad...:-D
Posted by: Mark Levine at February 15, 2005 11:59 AMI don't understand why a victim of a failure on the part of a company, doctor or whole industry, should be punished. Maybe the medical industry should try to eliminate or reduce the number of errors and accidents. Instead they just whine about how much they get sued and how much insurance they have to pay. Maybe if they took a little time to improve the standards of their field they might help drop some of the costs. This can be said for any other industries. They don't want to have to face the consequences of fraudulent business practices; shortcuts to save them money but cost people their lives in some cases.
Why should Merk not make dangerous products if it can still turn a profit because the penalties are so little that they don't impact the company's bottom line. If the company makes $100 million in profit off a drug that is dangerous every year and only has to pay $20 in settlements a year, it's still a profitable enterprise. Industries or companies that harm society should be given the corporate death penalty because they are a danger to the American people.
Have e-mailed Mark some questions for guest:
1) It is now revealed in the NY Times our White House had received 52 very clear warnings of what would be happening on 9-11. Much of it very clear and specific.
2) Would he now like to rethink the merits of Condolezza Rice's testimony before the Commission?
3) How does he feel about these unverefiable voting machines and why GOP leaders have been and still are insisting on them.
Dear Yes Now,
Those are very good questions. And, 90% of the time on Debate Tuesday, the debate is between someone who supports the Bush Administration and myself with any topic on the table for debate.
However, this Debate Tuesday is a bit different: it's a televised Doctor v. Lawyer debate on tort reform.
I promise you next Tuesday will be a more typical Bush Supporter v. Me debate and if you'll re-post these questions next week, I'll ask them then.
Posted by: Mark Levine at February 15, 2005 2:37 PMIf the medical community would chastise their own for bunglers that would help the patients as much or more in long run than malpractice suits.
I see the Bush administration merely acquiescing to the medical and mainly insurance corporation lobbiest in this matter. Taking care of their base!
Posted by: madfuq at February 15, 2005 3:06 PMDoctor, a question for you sir; Why don't you doctors band together and confront the insurance companies en masse and get them to be responsible in their charges that you incur?
Posted by: madfuq at February 15, 2005 3:27 PMTo the lawyer: What suggestions does he have to improve the situation?
Posted by: lyn at February 15, 2005 3:37 PMYour guests are way off mark when they talk about Social Health Care. Ask them to visit Finland and I persoally will show them a Scial Health Care System that works well despite every attempt by Doctors interested in their "private Prractice" to disrupt it.
And hardly any law suits!!!!
Posted by: Jacob Matthan at February 15, 2005 3:40 PMIs there proof that tort reform actually reduces malpractice premiums? If so, by how much?
Posted by: steve at February 15, 2005 3:47 PM